Difficulty: - TD.DIFFICULTIES (starting credits, lives, enemy hp/shield, kill reward), validated create-room / newgame option, state carries it; solo menu picker and co-op lobby picker (44px segmented control, reachable on every layout), HUD/room/end-screen labels, best-wave record per map AND difficulty (Normal keeps the legacy key), Play again keeps the running game's difficulty for host and guest Balance (12 bot runs, deterministic, 48/48 games replay identically in QA): - Normal ~71% bot wins at wave 30 (was 94%), Easy 100%, Hard 25% on open - credits tamed: reward growth 3% -> 2% per wave, clear bonus 10+2n -> 10+n, hp scaling eased, Rootkit pays 60 (was 100) but is tougher, flyers slower; unspent credits at wave 30: 1309 -> 335 - IDS Sniper is now a slow heavy hitter (essential, no longer sufficient: IDS-only dies by wave 7); Mortar, Arc and Filter buffed - Orbital Uplink price step per owned unit 30% (buy and upgrade) - remaining imbalances documented in docs/BALANCE.md Tests: difficulty (19) and balance (8) unit suites, 14-difficulty e2e, layout matrix reachability of the picker. 156 unit tests, 17 e2e scenarios. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Tb8pW2KAN4oFkh1aK1BfD8
14 KiB
Balance notes (tuned 2026-10-10, wave 4 pass; the untuned baseline was measured the same day)
public/js/sim.js holds the tuned tables. The numbers were measured with tools/bot.js, a headless player that drives the sim
through sim.cmd() / sim.preview(). No test pins a tuned number: test/sim.test.js and test/difficulty.test.js derive values
from the tables, and test/balance.test.js pins the design rules the pass relied on (credit budget, boss pay, upgrade
efficiency, IDS role, Uplink price share, difficulty ladder), each derived from the tables too.
The pass was time-boxed (12 runs of the bot, counting two short smoke tests of the tool itself; 8 seeds per cell in the final ones). With 8 seeds one win more or less is 12 points: read the tables as bands, not as exact rates.
What a player should notice
- Kill money is smaller and flatter: a defence earns about 22% fewer credits over 30 waves (7676 -> 5980), a boss is worth about half as much, and the clear bonus grows by 1 a wave instead of 2. Packet hit points are 14 to 21% lower than before (they scale slower), which pays the credit cut back: Normal stays winnable, but no longer by a wide margin.
- The IDS Sniper is now a slow heavy sniper (fewer, harder shots): the same damage per second as before against a tank, worse against a swarm of weak packets, so a defence made of IDS alone dies in the first swarm waves. It is still the backbone of every strong build against bosses and armour.
- Mortar, Arc and Filter are better value; upgrades are cheaper for them (and dearer for the IDS), so credits go into upgrading and into a mix.
- Flyers are slower (longer in range), Trojans and Rootkits are more armoured, the opening waves are unchanged.
Constants changed, and why (all in public/js/sim.js)
| constant | before | after | reason |
|---|---|---|---|
rewardScale(n) |
1 + 0.03 (n-1) | 1 + 0.02 (n-1) | late kills paid too much; credits snowballed |
Rootkit reward |
100 | 60 | a boss wave paid the price of ~2 IDS; now about one (wave 10: 127 -> 71 credits, wave 30 with 3 bosses: 561 -> 285) |
Rootkit buyCost |
300 | 180 | keeps the "about 3x the kill reward" rule of the future versus mode (docs/VERSUS.md number updated) |
| clear bonus | 10 + 2 n | 10 + n (CLEAR_BONUS, CLEAR_BONUS_PER_WAVE, clearBonus(n) exported) |
the bonus alone was 16% of all credits; only constants were extracted, the formula is the same |
hpScale(n) |
1 + 0.16 (n-1) + 0.022 (n-1)^2 | 1 + 0.145 (n-1) + 0.0165 (n-1)^2 | pays back the credit cut: 14% lower at wave 10, 19% at 20, 21% at 30 than the untuned game |
Trojan armor |
3 | 4 | armour should matter a little more against Filters |
Rootkit armor |
5 | 7 | same, and the boss is the IDS / Mortar / Uplink job |
Spoof (ghost) speed |
1.6 | 1.3 | flyers ignore the maze, so they get little time in range; they were a cliff at waves 7, 13, 15, 23 |
Botnet speed |
2.6 | 2.2 | same |
| IDS cost (L1/L2/L3) | 60 / 70 / 110 | 70 / 80 / 130 | the best tower per credit by far; 58 of them were built per game |
| IDS dmg | 50 / 85 / 150 | 83 / 143 / 250 | same dps against a tank as before... |
| IDS rate | 0.70 / 0.75 / 0.80 | 0.42 / 0.445 / 0.48 | ...but fewer shots, so swarms of weak packets are not its job (IDS-only now dies by wave 7) |
| IDS range | 6.5 / 7.2 / 8.0 | 6.2 / 6.8 / 7.5 | slightly less coverage per credit |
| IDS description | "...bosses." | "...bosses, poor against swarms." | the player is told |
| Filter range | 3.2 / 3.5 / 3.9 | 3.5 / 3.8 / 4.2 | the cheap swarm / anti-air tower had too little coverage |
| Filter upgrade cost (L2/L3) | 30 / 55 | 25 / 45 | an upgrade gave 58% of the dps per credit of a new tower |
| Mortar cost / dmg / range | 55 60 100 / 28 45 75 / 4.8 5.2 5.6 | 55 60 95 / 31 50 82 / 4.9 5.3 5.7 | far too weak; now the answer to ground swarms |
| Arc cost / dmg | 75 70 120 / 16 24 36 | 70 60 105 / 17 26 38 | far too weak alone; the first buff (dmg 20 30 44, 65 / 50 / 90) let Arc-only win 6 of 8 on open, so this is the middle |
| Arc range | 3.6 / 3.8 / 4.2 | 3.8 / 4.0 / 4.4 | |
DIFFICULTIES.hard |
gold 0.8, lives 0.7, hp 1.3, reward 0.9 | gold 0.9, lives 0.85, hp 1.08, reward 0.97 | the first row was a wall (0 wins in 35 games). The whole row (+8% hp, -3% rewards, -10% credits, -15% lives) takes open from 75% to 25% |
DIFFICULTIES.easy |
1.5 / 1.5 / 0.8 / 1.1 | unchanged | already 56 of 56 |
Not changed: START_GOLD 140, START_LIVES 20, WAVE_INTERVAL 28, SELL_RATIO 0.7, every waveGroups count and gap, Throttle,
Sandbox, Load Balancer, and the Orbital Uplink (1500 / 1200 / 2000 / 3200, each owned Uplink makes the next one and its
upgrades 30% dearer: the user's request, kept). Wall price and wall count are untouched on purpose (user decision: the maze stays strong).
Results (Normal unless stated; "win" = the wave 30 clear)
Before = the untuned numbers, 5 seeds. After = the shipped numbers, 8 seeds (Easy and Hard rows: maze@easy, maze@hard).
| mixed maze bot | before | after | target |
|---|---|---|---|
| open | 4/5 | 6/8 | 70-80% |
| twin | 5/5 | 5/8 | 50-70% |
| hub | 5/5 | 6/8 | 40-50% |
| canyon | 5/5 | 8/8 | 50-70% |
| archipelago | 5/5 | 5/8 | 50-70% |
| fortress | 4/5 | 5/8 | 50-70% |
| pinwheel | 5/5 | 5/8 | 40-50% |
| all maps | 33/35 (94%), 12-20 lives left | 40/56 (71%), 12 lives left (open 10) | about 58% |
| Easy, all maps | 35/35 | 56/56 (27-30 lives left of 30) | 90%+ |
| Hard, open / twin / hub | 0/35 on all maps (dies wave 7-29) | 2/8 / 1/8 / 0/8 (mean wave 25.6 / 21.5 / 20.9) | 20-35% on open |
| single-tower and ablation builds (8 seeds) | before | after |
|---|---|---|
| spam-ids (open+twin) | 35/35 (all maps) | 0/16, dies in wave 3-7 (swarm waves) |
| spam-filter (open+twin) | 0/35 (all maps), wave 12-23 | 0/16, wave 12-22 |
| spam-mortar (open, twin, hub) | 0/24, wave 6-8 (old doc) | 0/16 (open, twin), wave 6-8 (flyers: no anti-air) |
| spam-arc (open, twin, hub) | 0/24, wave 14-22 (old doc) | 0/16 (open, twin), wave 15-26 |
| mixed without IDS (open) | 0/5, dies wave 16-29 | 1/8 (mixed: 6/8) |
| mixed without Mortar (open) | not measured | 1/8 |
| mixed without Throttle (open) | not measured | 2/8 |
| mixed without Arc (open) | not measured | 6/8 |
| mixed without Filter (open) | not measured | 8/8 |
| economy (mixed bot) | before | after |
|---|---|---|
| credits paid by wave 10 / 15 / 20 / 25 / 30 (gold + invested, games that got that far, all maps) | 874 / 1551 / 2370 / 3560 / 6577 | 773 / 1320 / 2040 / 2860 / 5190 |
| credits in hand at wave 10 / 15 / 20 / 25 | 33 / 39 / 33 / 38 | 32 / 33 / 33 / 30 (always spent) |
| credits in hand at wave 30 (the bot stops buying when no wave is left to prepare for) | 1309 | 335 |
full-clear income to wave 30 (table arithmetic, income() in test/balance.test.js) |
7676 | 5980 |
| IDS towers at wave 30 (open / twin / hub) | 58 / 49 / 44 (80-97% of all damage) | 25 / 30 / 25 (49% / 76% / 69%) |
| lives lost in waves 1-5 (sum over games) | 5 in 35 games | 3 in 56 games |
Where the lives go (mixed bot, all maps): Rootkit leaks (5 lives each) 66% before and 53% after; then Trojans 15%, Spoofs 10%, Proxies 9%, Botnets 6%, Worms 5% (after).
Targets scorecard
| target | state |
|---|---|
| maze beats no-maze, no-maze survives the first 8-10 waves, lazy dies early, no leaks in waves 1-5 | holds (8 seeds): mixed maze 6/8, 5/8, 6/8 on open / twin / hub against no-maze 1/8, 0/8, 0/8 (they die at wave 21-30, on hub all 8 in the wave 30 boss wave); lazy dies in wave 9 / 4 / 7; waves 1-5 lose 3 lives in 56 games |
| Normal open 70-80% | 75% (6/8) |
| twin, new maps 50-70% | twin 63, archipelago 63, fortress 63; canyon 100% |
| hub, pinwheel 40-50% | 75% and 63%: a little easy (not fixable with global tables, see below) |
| every spam strategy loses | yes, all four 0/16 |
| each tower type matters in the best mix | IDS (1/8 without), Mortar (1/8), Throttle (2/8): yes. Filter and Arc: no (the mix wins as often, or more, without them) |
| credits neither pile up nor starve | spent to the credit at every wave up to 25 (30-33 in hand), 335 at wave 30 (1309 before) |
| Easy 90%+, Hard 20-35% on open | 100%, 25% |
Remaining known imbalances
- Filter and Arc do not pull their weight in the bot's best build. Without Filters the mixed build wins 8/8 (with: 6/8)
on
open; the bot over-buys them (23 onopenat wave 30, 18% of damage) because its surrogate overrates cheap towers. The bot buys almost no Arc (0 to 1.5 a game), though an Arc-only build now reaches wave 15-26. Either the towers still need a role (Arc: chain on dense late swarms, Filter: early game and flyers) or the bot's model undervalues them; a human playtest should decide. Throttle matters (2/8 without it). - IDS is still the backbone: 49 to 76% of the damage of the mixed builds and a build without it wins 1/8, but it is no longer sufficient (IDS-only dies in wave 3-7). A mixed build with ~25 IDS and a handful of Mortars is what the bot finds best.
- Map spread is not tunable with global tables.
canyon(rating 1) is a 100% map,hubandpinwheelare easier than asked,archipelagoandfortressare about right. Hard is tuned toopen(25%): ontwinandhubit is 0 to 12%. - Boss leaks decide games: a Rootkit that gets through costs 5 of 20 lives and is the main cause of death. They are
dangerous on purpose (the user wanted bosses to hurt); if playtests find it too swingy, lower the Rootkit
leakto 4 before touching hp. Rootkits walk about 200 s through a long maze, so they overlap 6 to 7 later waves when waves are called on the 28 s timer: the bot's per-wave life-loss log attributes such a leak to the wave that was current when it happened. - Sandbox, Load Balancer and Orbital Uplink are not valued well by the bot. It never builds a Sandbox and rarely a Load Balancer, so nothing can be said about them from the numbers. The Uplink was tested with a "save for it" rule: a bot that saves from wave 12 to 16 starves its defence and dies (1/8, mean wave 18.6) before it can pay 1500. Judged on paper: the first Uplink is 1500 = 25% of the 5980 credits a full run pays (the second 1950, the third 2540), and 1500 credits of IDS L1 is ~21 towers; the Uplink is an endless-mode purchase, not a way to win wave 30. Nothing was changed.
- The waves were not touched. Flyer waves (
(n-1) % 8= 4 and 6; from wave 14 with the Botnet swarm) and wave 28 are still where defences break first; the Daemon, Proxy and Botnet themselves are not a leading cause of lost lives (1 to 15% of leaks each). - The balance of Normal, Easy and Hard is steep: the whole Hard row (8% more packet hit points, 3% less pay, 10% fewer opening
credits, 15% fewer lives) moves
openfrom 75% to 25%. Re-measure after any number change, with at least 8 seeds.
Re-running the measurement
node tools/bot.js --maps open,twin,hub,canyon,archipelago,fortress,pinwheel \
--strategies "maze;maze@easy#open;maze@hard#open;maze-no-ids#open;maze-no-filter#open;maze-no-mortar#open;maze-no-arc#open;maze-no-throttle#open;spam-ids#open+twin;spam-arc#open+twin;spam-filter#open+twin;spam-mortar#open+twin" \
--seeds 8 --max 30 --verbose --json out.json
# the Easy (all maps) and Hard (open, twin, hub) rows of the results table
node tools/bot.js --maps open,twin,hub,canyon,archipelago,fortress,pinwheel \
--strategies "maze@easy;maze@hard#open+twin+hub" --seeds 8 --max 30 --verbose --json out-diff.json
(about 3 to 10 minutes on 6 cores; it uses all of them. --sim other/sim.js measures another copy; --json out.json --detail
for raw games; --gold N overrides the opening credits.) Strategy names: maze (the mixed build), nomaze, spam-<type>,
maze-no-<type>, lazy, full (mixed + Sandbox + Load Balancer + Uplink) and maze+<type> (mixed + one extra type), with
optional :key=value overrides (see DEFAULTS in the bot; use ; between strategies that carry them). A strategy can carry a
game difficulty after @ and the only maps it runs on after # (maze@hard#open+twin). The tables now print gold@25 and a
"credits seen" block (gold + everything invested, games that reached the wave only). Tips: results depend on the bot's own
heuristics as much as on the numbers; full and maze+uplink save for the Uplink from wave 16 (12 with the override), which starves the
defence, so do not read their rows as balance data; the bot waits for each wave to clear but calls the next one after at most 28 s; for a
Uplink experiment maze+uplink:uplinkFrom=12 makes it save for one from that wave.
The bot is deterministic: the same sim and the same seeds replay the same games, so every number above can be reproduced exactly
(an independent QA re-run of maze, maze@easy and maze@hard on open / hub / canyon, seeds 1-6, matched all 48 recorded games
move for move, outcome and lives left). maze@hard on canyon was not measured in the pass: 4 of 6 won in the QA re-run.
The bot's model of the support towers is crude: a Sandbox counts as a slow of stun / pulse, a Load Balancer as a fire-rate boost
on the turrets in its range, the Uplink as armour-ignoring damage with a pierce factor. Treat their rows as "not measured".
The untuned baseline (for the record; 8 seeds, waves up to 45, 2026-10-09)
| strategy | open | twin | hub |
|---|---|---|---|
| maze (mixed) | 8/8 win | 6/8 | 8/8 |
| nomaze | 7/8 (dies ~wave 29-43) | 0/8 (wave 29-30) | 0/8 (wave 29) |
| spam-ids | 8/8 win | 8/8 win | 8/8 win |
| spam-filter | 0/8 (wave 14-28) | 0/8 | 0/8 |
| spam-mortar | 0/8 (wave 8) | 0/8 (wave 6-8) | 0/8 (wave 6-7) |
| spam-arc | 0/8 (wave 14-22) | 0/8 | 0/8 |
| maze without IDS | 0/8 (wave 14-29) | 0/8 | 0/8 |
| lazy | dies wave 8-9 | wave 3-4 | wave 6 |
Its findings: IDS mandatory and sufficient; the maze a near-guaranteed win; no-maze too viable on open; the economy snowballed
(about 280 credits unspent at wave 30 and ~60 IDS per game) while the early game was tight. This pass answered them with the
credit cut, the sniper role for the IDS and better Mortar / Arc / Filter value; the wall rule was ruled out by the user.